• News
  • Construction
Executive roundtable

Multifamily construction strong, litigation lessens


Construction defect litigation is down, multifamily construction activity is up, and material costs appear to be rising at an accelerated rate.

The state of San Diego County's construction industry was the topic of a recent roundtable discussion at The Daily Transcript offices sponsored by Xpera Group.

"We are seeing much activity in the market," said Jerry Gammieri, American Assets Trust (NYSE: AAT) vice president of construction. "Multifamily is exploding everywhere."

Gammieri, whose real estate investment trust is heavily invested in both multifamily and retail assets and projects, said the fact there is so much construction in a county with such high barriers to entry is a testament to the strength of this market.

Scott Bedingfield, a principal with the commercial construction insurance firm of Cavignac & Associates, said the recent surge in construction followed eight years of pent-up demand.

"The public works came first and then the multifamily," Bedingfield said, adding that there are at least $1 billion worth of primarily multifamily projects in the pre-construction phase downtown.

Ted Bumgardner, president of the Xpera Group, a construction consulting and expert witness firm, said "our business has changed substantially within the past 12 months."

"Before, much more of our work was construction forensics and defect litigation. Now, we are seeing small and large commercial and for sale housing along with the multifamily, which has really accelerated within the past six months," Bumgardner said.

Mary Pendleton, a partner with the Ford Walker Haggerty & Behar LLP, civil litigation firm, said she also hasn't seen as much construction defect litigation work.

"People try to work things out," Pendleton said.

Erin Kennedy Clancy, an associate attorney with the civil litigation firm of Lorber Greenfield & Polito LLC, said her firm orchestrates monthly meetings "so as to avoid more problems down the road."

"And you have to get it into plain language," Pendleton added.

"You need to get involved with the contracts two years before you put a shovel in the ground," Bedingfield said.

Bumgardner agreed that the focus has to be on pre-construction.

"You should have water-testing mockups and an iPad-based inspection system that transmits the data to the senior inspector without leaving the site," Bumgardner said.

As many condominium developers have learned, even these safeguards are no guarantee of a litigation-free project.

"Many are going to be sued no matter how much they focus on risk management," Kennedy Clancy said.

While construction litigation can have a chilling effect on condominiums, apartments keep coming out of the ground.

Jeff Bunker, president of contracting for multifamily builder The Wermers Co., said not only is there a plethora of new multifamily projects, "there is an amenities arms race to see who has the best development."

Alan Nevin, Xpera Group economic and research director, said he doesn't expect these luxury apartment projects to remain as rentals forever.

"These developers are building future (condominium) conversions," Nevin said.

Whether these units will be apartments or condominiums, Brian Cahill, Balfour Beatty Construction division president, said that "millenials can't afford houses and they want to be downtown."

Cahill said he knows of at least 7,000 units in the planning stages in downtown San Diego and that it might not be enough.

"The millenials are coming and they are pushing the baby boomers out," Cahill said.

Nevin, who is tracking as many as 20,000 rental units that are either under construction or in the pipeline around the county, said while affordable units are being built and luxury apartments are going up, apartments aren't being built for those who live in the middle.

"The problem isn't so much that we haven't built enough apartments, it is that we're not building enough Class B Apartments," Nevin said, adding that high fees and land costs make such a project virtually impossible.

Both Cahill and Bunker noted that regardless of whether there will still be an apartment surplus or shortage, finding subcontractors for these projects hasn't been easy.

"They are hard to get a hold of and that's driving prices up," Bunker said.

Cahill said a major reason there is a shortage of subcontractors is young people simply aren't getting into the construction field, which creates a major problem since it takes years to gain the required experience.

"I was shocked to see that we're already seeing labor shortages," Bumgardner added. "Substantial shortages exist for a technically competent workforce."

"We have contemplated hiring subcontractors directly," Bunker said. "Finding framing people got really difficult."

Nevin said there is a huge experience and generational gap in construction.

"Either they are unskilled kids or they are over 50," Nevin said.

Bunker said that what is making things even more difficult is about a 20 percent increase in cost for wood framing.

"Framing went from $15 to $20 percent a foot overnight," Bunker said.

Roundtable Participants

Sean Allen, Partner, Lorber Greenfield & Polito LLC

Scott Bedingfield, Principal, Cavignac & Associates

Ted Bumgardner, President, Xpera Group (roundtable sponsor)

Jeff Bunker, President of Contracting, Wermers Multi-Family Corporation

Brian Cahill, Southwest Division President, Balfour Beatty Construction

Jerry Gammieri, Vice President, American Assets Construction

Erin Kennedy Clancy, Associate, Lorber Greenfield & Polito LLC

Alan Nevin, Director of Economic & Market Research, Xpera Group

Mary Pendleton, Partner, Ford Walker Haggerty & Behar LLP

User Response
0 UserComments