• News
  • General

Foreign buyers hate fakes unless they're shopping

Related Special Reports

GUANGZHOU, China (AP) -- Thousands of foreign buyers flock to this southern city at this time of year for China's biggest trade show. They search for factory owners who will make their products cheaply and won't rip off their clever designs.

Then, they slip across town to malls loaded with fake Prada purses, phony Rolex watches and pirated Tod's loafers -- all sold at a fraction of the original's price.

"I've been in these stores where when you ask for knockoffs, they take you into a back room with shelves lined with fake handbags," said a footwear buyer from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, who only identified herself as Kathy because she feared problems with customs.

The shopping shows how the piracy problem is much more complex than it is usually portrayed. It's not just about creative foreign companies who are struggling to keep unscrupulous Chinese copycats from stealing their ideas. Often, the foreigners behave in a way that encourages the theft of intellectual property.

"Many buyers come here and talk about intellectual property rights, but then they'll show you their rival's product and ask if you can copy it," said Alyn Wong, a sales representative for a luggage company in the eastern province of Fujian. "It seems kind of contradictory. But that's the way the market works."

Wong was surrounded by colorful backpacks with the slogan "Love-Take Off-Good" in her company's booth at the Canton Fair, a biannual event that for five decades has been China's biggest trade fair. The show offers a head-spinning variety of goods -- everything from saxophones, fishing lures and hammers to espresso cups, toothbrushes and motorcycles.

Attendance at the show plunged last year at the start of the global financial crisis. But in a possible sign of the economy's recovery, the number of visitors started to bounce back at its 15-day autumn session, which ended Wednesday, organizers said. The event attracted 188,170 foreign buyers -- a 13.7 percent increase from the session last spring, they said.

Although there's a thick atmosphere of giddy dealmaking and browsing at the fair, there's also a palpable sense of paranoia. Most exhibitors won't allow photographs of their goods for fear the pictures will be used to copy their products. Chinese citizens aren't even allowed to attend unless they have a special pass as an exhibitor, translator or domestic buyer -- a process that involves an arduous background check.

During the middle of the fair, U.S. Commerce Secretary Gary Locke spoke at a conference about intellectual property rights at a hotel across the street from the massive fair complex.

"If innovators fear that their inventions or ideas will be stolen, then one of two things will happen: They'll either stop inventing, or they'll decide to create their inventions elsewhere," he said.

His speech focused on what China needed to do to combat piracy. Tougher laws and more crackdowns were needed, he said. His message: It was mostly China's problem.

But most of the shoppers strolling around the warren of tiny boutiques at the Guangzhou Baiyun World Leather Trading Center were foreigners. They were haggling and snapping up an eye-popping array of fake designer goods in the three-story mall, about a half-hour taxi ride away from the Canton Fair. Shops with names like Ladybug, Teli and QQ Bear were full of bags emblazoned with the Gucci, Coach and Prada logos.

In the mall's lobby, a special roped-off hospitality zone was set up for Canton Fair visitors. They sat on plastic chairs at tables covered in red cloth. Each had a candy dish full of fake peppermint Lifesaver candies. A nearby sign offered free translation services for the shoppers.

"Our business always picks up during the Canton Fair," said a store owner whose business card only identified him as Mr. Chen. "The foreigners do like to buy knockoffs."

One middle-aged man with a British accent marched into a store, pointed to a beige-checkered Louis Vuitton handbag and said excitedly, "That's the bag! That's the bag!" After a quick negotiation, he turned to a friend and said with a giggle, "They want 260 renminbi! That's only $40!"

The shops place all the purchased goods in nondescript black plastic garbage bags that don't have store logos on them. The shoppers all look like they got lost while taking out the trash and ended up at the mall.

None of the customers or shopkeepers would give their full names because they didn't want any problems with the authorities. But fake goods were all displayed in the open, and in the mall's lobby, there were two huge signs with product quality slogans from the Industrial and Commercial Administration Bureau.

In one shop, three uniformed officers with the People's Armed Police shopped for Louis Vuitton bags.

"This is fake leather, isn't it?" one said to a sales clerk.

"No way. Do you think we'd dare sell fake leather to someone like you?" she replied.

The shoppers rationalized their purchases in many ways. Some just shrugged off the ethical issue, saying they only bought one or two bags as fun souvenirs.

A businessman from Lebanon who was trying on a pair of Louis Vuitton loafers for 300 yuan ($44) said the shoes would probably last only three weeks and he would buy the real thing eventually. The man, who wouldn't give his name, said he felt a little guilty.

"But sometimes when you go to a store that's supposed to be selling the real thing," he added, "they will sell fakes."

User Response
0 UserComments